Feature: Book Genie Mode - Automated Testing with Detailed Reporting
File name: BookGenie.feature
Relative path: features/BookGenie.feature
Scenario Outline: Book Genie Response Validation with Citation Verification
When
I open the Creative Workspace login page
00:00:02.652
Then
I should see the homepage
00:00:00.039
When
I click on the mode selection dropdown
00:00:00.000
Then
I can see the "BookGenieQA" mode
00:00:00.000
And
I select the "BookGenieQA" mode
00:00:00.000
Then
I type "Suggest 5 books on christmas" on chat input element
00:00:03.471
And
I wait for AI to complete thinking
00:00:21.427
And
I validate the response is visible for "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
00:00:00.026
And
I extract book data from BookGenie response
00:00:00.020
And
I save BookGenie book data to Excel file for query "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
00:00:00.016
And
I validate each book individually against Excel file for query "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
00:00:00.016
CITATION VALIDATION DETAILED REPORT ================================================================================ BOOK: Christmas Miracles ------------------------------------------------------------ ✅ Reason 1: PASS (100%) ✅ Reason 2: PASS (100%) ✅ Reason 3: PASS (100%) ✅ Reason 4: PASS (100%) BOOK: Christmas 101 ------------------------------------------------------------ ✅ Reason 1: PASS (100%) ✅ Reason 2: PASS (100%) ✅ Reason 3: PASS (100%) ✅ Reason 4: PASS (100%) BOOK: The Official Guide to Christmas in the South ------------------------------------------------------------ ✅ Reason 1: PASS (95%) ❌ Reason 2: FAIL (0%) 📝 Reason: It humorously navigates through the holiday season, revealing the finer and sometimes unspoken detai... 📚 Citation: emphasizing that its presentation is as crucial as the dish, reflecting deep-seated cultural etiquet... ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "emphasizing that its presentation is as crucial as the dish, reflecting deep-seated cultural etiquette and social standing" ❌ Reason 3: FAIL (0%) 📝 Reason: The guide emphasizes that the presentation is as crucial as the dish, reflecting deep-seated cultura... 📚 Citation: No citation found... ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found" BOOK: The First Christmas ------------------------------------------------------------ ✅ Reason 1: PASS (95%) ✅ Reason 2: PASS (100%) ✅ Reason 3: PASS (100%) BOOK: Christmas Cake ------------------------------------------------------------ ✅ Reason 1: PASS (100%) ✅ Reason 2: PASS (100%) ✅ Reason 3: PASS (100%) SUMMARY: 15/17 reasons passed (88.2%) OVERALL STATUS: PASS
Citation Validation Summary: 15/17 passed
📊 Citation Validation Report
Generated on 10/1/2025, 2:43:44 PM
📖 Christmas Miracles
✅ Reason 1: 100% match
✅ Reason 2: 100% match
✅ Reason 3: 100% match
✅ Reason 4: 100% match
📖 Christmas 101
✅ Reason 1: 100% match
✅ Reason 2: 100% match
✅ Reason 3: 100% match
✅ Reason 4: 100% match
📖 The Official Guide to Christmas in the South
✅ Reason 1: 95% match
❌ Reason 2: 0% match
⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "emphasizing that its presentation is as crucial as the dish, reflecting deep-seated cultural etiquette and social standing"
❌ Reason 3: 0% match
⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
📖 The First Christmas
✅ Reason 1: 95% match
✅ Reason 2: 100% match
✅ Reason 3: 100% match
📖 Christmas Cake
✅ Reason 1: 100% match
✅ Reason 2: 100% match
✅ Reason 3: 100% match
📈 Validation Summary
Total Reasons Validated: 17
Passed: 15
Failed: 2
Pass Rate: 88.2%
Overall Status: PASS
Then
I verify database connectivity
00:00:00.176
And
database should contain 2020 books
00:00:00.100
And
I validate extracted books individually against database
00:00:00.487
And
I validate BookGenie response relevance with AI for query "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
00:00:38.625
+ Show Info
+ Show Info
PER-BOOK AI VALIDATION REPORT - Query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
================================================================================
OVERALL RELEVANCE SCORE: 75%
STATUS: FAIL
BOOKS ANALYZED: 5
BOOK 1: "Christmas Miracles"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 95%
SECTION SCORES:
Author Information: 100% - Complete author information provided, correctly identifying all three authors.
Publishing Date: 90% - A specific publishing date is provided. While not recent, it's appropriate for this type of evergreen content.
Why Match Explanations: 95% - The explanations are excellent, providing specific details like 'heartwarming stories,' 'compassion,' and mentions of specific story titles within the book. They strongly justify the book's relevance.
Relevance Scores: 95% - The 98% score is very well-justified by the 'Gap' explanation, which correctly notes the book's specific focus on miracles within the broader Christmas theme.
DETAILED FEEDBACK:
• This is a high-quality, relevant recommendation that directly addresses the user's query.
• All sections are well-supported with specific details from the book.
• The justification for the relevance score is nuanced and logical.
• The inclusion of internal tags like '(manuscript)' and '(metadata)' is distracting and should be removed from the user-facing text.
IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
• Remove internal-facing tags like '(manuscript)' and '(metadata)' from the explanation text to improve readability.
================================================================================
BOOK 2: "Christmas 101"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 95%
SECTION SCORES:
Author Information: 100% - Author information is complete and accurate.
Publishing Date: 90% - The publishing date is provided and is appropriate for a book on Christmas traditions and recipes.
Why Match Explanations: 95% - The justification is strong, correctly identifying the book as a guide to 'festive entertaining' and highlighting its focus on culinary traditions, history, and even movie recommendations.
Relevance Scores: 95% - The 97% score is well-justified. The 'Gap' explanation logically points out that its primary focus on entertaining may not cover all holiday themes.
DETAILED FEEDBACK:
• Excellent recommendation that provides a different but highly relevant type of Christmas book (a guide/cookbook).
• The explanations effectively communicate the book's content and its relevance to the query.
• The analysis of the relevance score is consistent and logical.
IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
• The response was truncated ('...'). Ensure the full text is presented to the user for a complete explanation.
================================================================================
BOOK 3: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 60%
SECTION SCORES:
Author Information: 0% - Critical failure: Author information is completely missing.
Publishing Date: 0% - Critical failure: Publishing date is completely missing.
Why Match Explanations: 90% - The explanations are very good, clearly describing the book's specific niche as a humorous guide to Southern Christmas traditions.
Relevance Scores: 90% - The 95% score and its 'Gap' justification are excellent, correctly identifying that the book's regional focus might limit its relevance for a general audience.
DETAILED FEEDBACK:
• The analysis of the book's content and relevance is strong and insightful.
• However, the recommendation is severely hampered by the complete omission of basic metadata: author and publishing date. This is a major data retrieval failure.
IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
• Must include author and publishing date for every book. This is essential, non-negotiable information.
================================================================================
BOOK 4: "The First Christmas"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 60%
SECTION SCORES:
Author Information: 0% - Critical failure: Author information is completely missing.
Publishing Date: 0% - Critical failure: Publishing date is completely missing.
Why Match Explanations: 90% - The match explanations are clear and effective, correctly identifying the book's focus on the religious origins of the holiday.
Relevance Scores: 90% - The 94% score is supported by a very logical 'Gap' explanation that notes the book's specific religious focus may not cover broader cultural traditions.
DETAILED FEEDBACK:
• The conceptual analysis of why this book is a match is excellent.
• The failure to retrieve and display the author and publishing date is a critical error that makes the recommendation incomplete and less useful.
IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
• Always provide author and publishing date. This information is fundamental to a book recommendation.
================================================================================
BOOK 5: "Christmas Cake"
------------------------------------------------------------
Overall Score: 65%
SECTION SCORES:
Author Information: 0% - Critical failure: Author information is completely missing.
Publishing Date: 0% - Critical failure: Publishing date is completely missing.
Why Match Explanations: 85% - The explanations are good, establishing the book as a novel set at Christmas time and mentioning its key themes and the narrative's culmination on Christmas Eve.
Relevance Scores: 90% - The 93% score is well-defended. The 'Gap' explanation correctly points out that the book uses Christmas as a setting for broader themes, which slightly reduces its direct focus compared to other suggestions.
DETAILED FEEDBACK:
• This is a good example of recommending fiction relevant to the query.
• The analysis of the book's themes and setting is strong.
• As with the previous two books, the lack of author and date information is a major flaw that undermines the quality of the recommendation.
IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
• Ensure that essential metadata like author and publishing date is always included in the response.
================================================================================
SUMMARY FEEDBACK:
----------------------------------------
• The response provides a good variety of book types (inspirational, guide, regional, religious, fiction) that are all highly relevant to the broad query.
• The 'Why this is a match' and 'Gap' explanations are a major strength of the response. They are consistently insightful, well-written, and provide excellent justification for the selections and scores.
• There is a systemic data retrieval failure, as author and publishing date are missing for three out of the five books. This significantly degrades the overall quality and usefulness of the response.
OVERALL IMPROVEMENT SUGGESTIONS:
----------------------------------------
• Prioritize fixing the data retrieval issue to ensure that author and publication date are always provided for every book.
• Remove any internal-facing system tags (e.g., '(manuscript)') from the final response to improve clarity and professionalism.
• Ensure that explanations are not truncated, as seen in the second book's description.
🤖 PER-BOOK AI Response Relevance Validation
Query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
Overall Relevance Score: 75%
Status: FAIL
Books Analyzed: 5
Individual Book Analyses
📖 Book 1: "Christmas Miracles" - 95%
Author Information: 100%
Complete author information provided, correctly identifying all three authors.
Publishing Date: 90%
A specific publishing date is provided. While not recent, it's appropriate for this type of evergreen content.
Why Match Explanations: 95%
The explanations are excellent, providing specific details like 'heartwarming stories,' 'compassion,' and mentions of specific story titles within the book. They strongly justify the book's relevance.
Relevance Scores: 95%
The 98% score is very well-justified by the 'Gap' explanation, which correctly notes the book's specific focus on miracles within the broader Christmas theme.
Improvement Suggestions:
💡 Remove internal-facing tags like '(manuscript)' and '(metadata)' from the explanation text to improve readability.
📖 Book 2: "Christmas 101" - 95%
Author Information: 100%
Author information is complete and accurate.
Publishing Date: 90%
The publishing date is provided and is appropriate for a book on Christmas traditions and recipes.
Why Match Explanations: 95%
The justification is strong, correctly identifying the book as a guide to 'festive entertaining' and highlighting its focus on culinary traditions, history, and even movie recommendations.
Relevance Scores: 95%
The 97% score is well-justified. The 'Gap' explanation logically points out that its primary focus on entertaining may not cover all holiday themes.
Improvement Suggestions:
💡 The response was truncated ('...'). Ensure the full text is presented to the user for a complete explanation.
📖 Book 3: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - 60%
Author Information: 0%
Critical failure: Author information is completely missing.
Publishing Date: 0%
Critical failure: Publishing date is completely missing.
Why Match Explanations: 90%
The explanations are very good, clearly describing the book's specific niche as a humorous guide to Southern Christmas traditions.
Relevance Scores: 90%
The 95% score and its 'Gap' justification are excellent, correctly identifying that the book's regional focus might limit its relevance for a general audience.
Improvement Suggestions:
💡 Must include author and publishing date for every book. This is essential, non-negotiable information.
📖 Book 4: "The First Christmas" - 60%
Author Information: 0%
Critical failure: Author information is completely missing.
Publishing Date: 0%
Critical failure: Publishing date is completely missing.
Why Match Explanations: 90%
The match explanations are clear and effective, correctly identifying the book's focus on the religious origins of the holiday.
Relevance Scores: 90%
The 94% score is supported by a very logical 'Gap' explanation that notes the book's specific religious focus may not cover broader cultural traditions.
Improvement Suggestions:
💡 Always provide author and publishing date. This information is fundamental to a book recommendation.
📖 Book 5: "Christmas Cake" - 65%
Author Information: 0%
Critical failure: Author information is completely missing.
Publishing Date: 0%
Critical failure: Publishing date is completely missing.
Why Match Explanations: 85%
The explanations are good, establishing the book as a novel set at Christmas time and mentioning its key themes and the narrative's culmination on Christmas Eve.
Relevance Scores: 90%
The 93% score is well-defended. The 'Gap' explanation correctly points out that the book uses Christmas as a setting for broader themes, which slightly reduces its direct focus compared to other suggestions.
Improvement Suggestions:
💡 Ensure that essential metadata like author and publishing date is always included in the response.
Summary Feedback
• The response provides a good variety of book types (inspirational, guide, regional, religious, fiction) that are all highly relevant to the broad query.
• The 'Why this is a match' and 'Gap' explanations are a major strength of the response. They are consistently insightful, well-written, and provide excellent justification for the selections and scores.
• There is a systemic data retrieval failure, as author and publishing date are missing for three out of the five books. This significantly degrades the overall quality and usefulness of the response.
Overall Improvement Suggestions
💡 Prioritize fixing the data retrieval issue to ensure that author and publication date are always provided for every book.
💡 Remove any internal-facing system tags (e.g., '(manuscript)') from the final response to improve clarity and professionalism.
💡 Ensure that explanations are not truncated, as seen in the second book's description.
=== SCENARIO LOGS: Book Genie Response Validation with Citation Verification ===
[2:39:59 PM] Navigating to Creative Workspace login page
[2:40:02 PM] Homepage visibility: false
[2:40:02 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:02 PM] ℹ️ Preparing to type query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:02 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for chat input to be visible
[2:40:04 PM] ℹ️ Clearing chat input
[2:40:04 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:05 PM] ℹ️ Pressing Enter to submit query
[2:40:06 PM] ✅ Query submitted successfully: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:06 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for AI to complete thinking...
[2:40:06 PM] 📋 WAITING FOR AI RESPONSE
[2:40:06 PM] ℹ️ Looking for AI thinking indicator...
[2:40:06 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to appear (max 2 minutes)
[2:40:07 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking indicator appeared - AI is processing the request
[2:40:07 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to disappear (max 5 minutes)
[2:40:24 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking completed - Response should be ready
[2:40:24 PM] ℹ️ Allowing additional time for response rendering
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ AI response wait process completed
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating response for query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 VALIDATING RESPONSE FOR QUERY: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Locating the latest response in chat
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for response to be visible (max 30 seconds)
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ Response received - Length: 5455 characters
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Response preview: Watch Me WorkInterpreting context for your query...Retrieving Relevant Books for 'books with a Chris...
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Extracting book data from response...
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 EXTRACTING BOOK DATA FROM RESPONSE
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Locating BookGenie response container
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from response
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ HTML content extracted - Length: 41536 characters
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract book data
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED 5 BOOKS
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 EXTRACTED BOOKS SUMMARY
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 1. "Christmas Miracles" - Score: 98%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 2. "Christmas 101" - Score: 97%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 3. "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Score: 95%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 4. "The First Christmas" - Score: 94%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 5. "Christmas Cake" - Score: 93%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📊 Total books extracted: 5
[2:40:27 PM] 📊 Average relevance score: 95%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ Extracted 5 books from response
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Saving 5 books to Excel file: test_results/suggest_5_books_on_christmas.xlsx
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 SAVING BOOKS TO EXCEL FILE
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Target file path: test_results/suggest_5_books_on_christmas.xlsx
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Exporting 5 books to Excel format
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ Book data saved to: test_results/suggest_5_books_on_christmas.xlsx
[2:40:27 PM] 📊 File verified - Size: 19.79 KB
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✓ Excel file creation verified successfully
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 STARTING INDIVIDUAL BOOK VALIDATION (5 books) for query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 1: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "Christmas Miracles" vs expected: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 98% vs expected: 98%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 98% (expected 98%)
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 4 vs expected 4
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 4 points (expected 4)
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 1 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Book 1 validation completed
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 2: "Christmas 101"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "Christmas 101" vs expected: "Christmas 101"
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "Christmas 101"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 97% vs expected: 97%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 97% (expected 97%)
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 4 vs expected 4
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 4 points (expected 4)
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 2 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Book 2 validation completed
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 3: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" vs expected: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 95% vs expected: 95%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 95% (expected 95%)
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3)
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 3 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Book 3 validation completed
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 4: "The First Christmas"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "The First Christmas" vs expected: "The First Christmas"
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "The First Christmas"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 94% vs expected: 94%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 94% (expected 94%)
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3)
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 4 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Book 4 validation completed
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 5: "Christmas Cake"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "Christmas Cake" vs expected: "Christmas Cake"
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "Christmas Cake"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 93% vs expected: 93%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 93% (expected 93%)
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3)
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 5 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Book 5 validation completed
[2:40:27 PM] 📊 VALIDATION SUMMARY: 5/5 books passed
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ALL BOOKS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY!
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING REASON-CITATION MATCHES
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Starting citation validation process...
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 🚀 STARTING COMPLETE CITATION VALIDATION WORKFLOW
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Step 1: Extracting books from AI response
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 EXTRACTING BOOK DATA FROM RESPONSE
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Locating BookGenie response container
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from response
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ HTML content extracted - Length: 41536 characters
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract book data
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED 5 BOOKS
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 EXTRACTED BOOKS SUMMARY
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 1. "Christmas Miracles" - Score: 98%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 2. "Christmas 101" - Score: 97%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 3. "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Score: 95%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 4. "The First Christmas" - Score: 94%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 5. "Christmas Cake" - Score: 93%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📊 Total books extracted: 5
[2:40:27 PM] 📊 Average relevance score: 95%
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Step 2: Extracting citation texts from book elements
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 📚 EXTRACTING CITATION TEXTS FROM BOOK ELEMENTS
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Step 1: Waiting for main book section
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Found 16 total accordion sections
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "1. Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "2. Christmas 101"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "3. The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "4. The First Christmas"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "5. Christmas Cake"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Processing 5 individual book sections
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 1: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:30 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:30 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:33 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:33 PM] ℹ️ Found 4 citation buttons for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:33 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/4 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:33 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 1 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 1
[2:40:36 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): "Christmas Miracles" explores the profound impact of resilience and transformative human connection...
[2:40:36 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 1
[2:40:38 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 1 closed successfully
[2:40:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 99)
[2:40:38 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/4 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:38 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 2 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:39 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 2
[2:40:41 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): compassion, selflessness, and the prioritization of giving love...
[2:40:41 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 2
[2:40:43 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 2 closed successfully
[2:40:43 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 63)
[2:40:43 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/4 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:43 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 3 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:44 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 3
[2:40:46 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Christmas Mystery...
[2:40:46 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 3
[2:40:47 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 3 closed successfully
[2:40:47 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 17)
[2:40:47 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 4/4 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:47 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 4 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:48 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 4
[2:40:50 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): grand and subtle miracles that defy natural explanation...
[2:40:50 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 4
[2:40:52 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 4 closed successfully
[2:40:52 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 4 extracted successfully (length: 55)
[2:40:52 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:54 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:54 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "Christmas Miracles" - 4 citations extracted
[2:40:54 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 2: "Christmas 101"
[2:40:54 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "Christmas 101"
[2:40:57 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "Christmas 101"
[2:40:57 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "Christmas 101"
[2:41:00 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "Christmas 101"
[2:41:00 PM] ℹ️ Found 4 citation buttons for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:00 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/4 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:00 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 1 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:01 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 1
[2:41:03 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): "CHRISTMAS 101" honors the culinary legacy of Dick and Eleanor Rodgers, transforming their tradition...
[2:41:03 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 1
[2:41:04 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 1 closed successfully
[2:41:04 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 159)
[2:41:04 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/4 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:04 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 2 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:05 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 2
[2:41:07 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): blends historical practices with contemporary artistry...
[2:41:07 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 2
[2:41:09 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 2 closed successfully
[2:41:09 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 54)
[2:41:09 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/4 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:09 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 3 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:10 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 3
[2:41:12 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Gisela’s Deluxe Fruitcake...
[2:41:12 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 3
[2:41:14 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 3 closed successfully
[2:41:14 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 25)
[2:41:14 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 4/4 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:14 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 4 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:15 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 4
[2:41:17 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): including *A Charlie Brown Christmas* and *It's a Wonderful Life*...
[2:41:17 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 4
[2:41:18 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 4 closed successfully
[2:41:18 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 4 extracted successfully (length: 65)
[2:41:18 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "Christmas 101"
[2:41:20 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "Christmas 101"
[2:41:20 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "Christmas 101" - 4 citations extracted
[2:41:20 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 3: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:20 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:23 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:23 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:26 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:26 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 citation buttons for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:26 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/3 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:26 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 1 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:27 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 1
[2:41:29 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): charming, humorous guide, anyone can learn how to deck the halls, Southern style...
[2:41:29 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 1
[2:41:31 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 1 closed successfully
[2:41:31 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 80)
[2:41:31 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/3 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:31 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 2 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:32 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 2
[2:41:44 PM] ❌ Error extracting citation 2 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South": TimeoutError: locator.waitFor: Timeout 10000ms exceeded.
Call log:
- waiting for locator('[class*="BookCitation-module_paragraph"] span[id*="quotes-citations"]').first() to be visible
[2:41:44 PM] ⚠ ⚠️ Citation 2 extraction failed or returned empty
[2:41:44 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/3 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:44 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 3 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:45 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 3
[2:41:47 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): emphasizing that its presentation is as crucial as the dish, reflecting deep-seated cultural etiquet...
[2:41:47 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 3
[2:41:48 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 3 closed successfully
[2:41:48 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 122)
[2:41:48 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:50 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:50 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - 2 citations extracted
[2:41:50 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 4: "The First Christmas"
[2:41:50 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "The First Christmas"
[2:41:53 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "The First Christmas"
[2:41:53 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "The First Christmas"
[2:41:56 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "The First Christmas"
[2:41:56 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 citation buttons for "The First Christmas"
[2:41:56 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/3 for "The First Christmas"
[2:41:56 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 1 for "The First Christmas"
[2:41:57 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 1
[2:41:59 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): The stories of Jesus’s birth are the foundation of the world’s most widely observed holiday...
[2:41:59 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 1
[2:42:01 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 1 closed successfully
[2:42:01 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 91)
[2:42:01 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/3 for "The First Christmas"
[2:42:01 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 2 for "The First Christmas"
[2:42:02 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 2
[2:42:04 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): a beacon of light, the fulfillment of ancient prophecies, and a source of universal joy...
[2:42:04 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 2
[2:42:05 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 2 closed successfully
[2:42:05 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 87)
[2:42:05 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/3 for "The First Christmas"
[2:42:05 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 3 for "The First Christmas"
[2:42:06 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 3
[2:42:08 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): the real Christmas story buried in the familiar Bible accounts...
[2:42:08 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 3
[2:42:10 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 3 closed successfully
[2:42:10 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 62)
[2:42:10 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "The First Christmas"
[2:42:11 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "The First Christmas"
[2:42:11 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "The First Christmas" - 3 citations extracted
[2:42:12 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 5: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:12 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:15 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:15 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:18 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:18 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 citation buttons for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:18 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/3 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:18 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 1 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:19 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 1
[2:42:21 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): dramatic culmination around Christmas Eve...
[2:42:21 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 1
[2:42:22 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 1 closed successfully
[2:42:22 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 41)
[2:42:22 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/3 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:22 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 2 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:23 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 2
[2:42:25 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): a heartwarming story that celebrates the close and lifelong bonds among women...
[2:42:25 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 2
[2:42:27 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 2 closed successfully
[2:42:27 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 77)
[2:42:27 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/3 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:27 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 3 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:28 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 3
[2:42:30 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): issues of life and death, faith and love—and good cooking!...
[2:42:30 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 3
[2:42:31 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 3 closed successfully
[2:42:31 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 58)
[2:42:31 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "Christmas Cake" - 3 citations extracted
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ 🎉 Successfully extracted citations from 5 books
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Step 3: Validating reason-citation matches
[2:42:33 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING REASON-CITATION MATCHES (80% THRESHOLD)
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 4 reasons for: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Reason 1: Checking match...
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas Miracles" - Reason 1: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Reason 2: Checking match...
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas Miracles" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Reason 3: Checking match...
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas Miracles" - Reason 3: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Reason 4: Checking match...
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas Miracles" - Reason 4: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 4 reasons for: "Christmas 101"
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Reason 1: Checking match...
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas 101" - Reason 1: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Reason 2: Checking match...
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas 101" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Reason 3: Checking match...
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas 101" - Reason 3: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Reason 4: Checking match...
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas 101" - Reason 4: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Reason 1: Checking match...
[2:42:42 PM] ✅ ✅ "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Reason 1: 95% match - PASS
[2:42:42 PM] ℹ️ Reason 2: Checking match...
[2:43:23 PM] ❌ ❌ "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Reason 2: 0% match - FAIL
[2:43:23 PM] ❌ ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "emphasizing that its presentation is as crucial as the dish, reflecting deep-seated cultural etiquette and social standing"
[2:43:23 PM] ℹ️ Reason 3: Checking match...
[2:43:34 PM] ❌ ❌ "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Reason 3: 0% match - FAIL
[2:43:34 PM] ❌ ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[2:43:34 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "The First Christmas"
[2:43:34 PM] ℹ️ Reason 1: Checking match...
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ "The First Christmas" - Reason 1: 95% match - PASS
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Reason 2: Checking match...
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ "The First Christmas" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Reason 3: Checking match...
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ "The First Christmas" - Reason 3: 100% match - PASS
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "Christmas Cake"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Reason 1: Checking match...
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas Cake" - Reason 1: 100% match - PASS
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Reason 2: Checking match...
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas Cake" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Reason 3: Checking match...
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas Cake" - Reason 3: 100% match - PASS
[2:43:44 PM] 📊 📊 CITATION VALIDATION SUMMARY: 15/17 passed (88.2%)
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ 🎉 REASON-CITATION VALIDATION: OVERALL PASSED
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Step 4: Generating detailed report
[2:43:44 PM] 📋 📋 GENERATING CITATION VALIDATION REPORT
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Report generated: 15/17 reasons passed
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation workflow completed successfully
[2:43:44 PM] 📊 📈 OVERALL CITATION VALIDATION: 15/17 (88.2%)
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ REASON-CITATION VALIDATION: OVERALL PASSED
[2:43:44 PM] 📋 📋 GENERATING DETAILED CITATION VALIDATION REPORT
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Generating HTML citation validation report
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ Generated HTML report for 17 reasons
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation HTML report generated and attached
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation plain text report attached
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking database connectivity...
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Database connected successfully
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Database path: /home/runner/work/HC_Epub_Automation/HC_Epub_Automation/tests/test_data/database.xlsx
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Total books: 5455
[2:43:44 PM] 📊 Database contains 5455 books
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Database book count requirement met: 5455 >= 2020
[2:43:44 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING EXTRACTED BOOKS INDIVIDUALLY AGAINST DATABASE
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 1/5: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "Christmas Miracles" → "Christmas Miracles"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 2/5: "Christmas 101"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "Christmas 101"
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "Christmas 101" → "Christmas 101"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 3/5: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" → "He"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 4/5: "The First Christmas"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "The First Christmas"
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "The First Christmas" → "He"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 5/5: "Christmas Cake"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "Christmas Cake"
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "Christmas Cake" → "Christmas Cake"
[2:43:44 PM] 📊 INDIVIDUAL DATABASE VALIDATION SUMMARY: 5/5 books found in database
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ 🎉 ALL BOOKS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY AGAINST DATABASE!
[2:43:44 PM] 📋 🤖 VALIDATING RESPONSE RELEVANCE WITH GEMINI AI - PER BOOK ANALYSIS
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Starting Gemini AI per-book relevance validation...
[2:43:44 PM] 📋 🤖 ANALYZING RESPONSE RELEVANCE WITH GEMINI AI - PER BOOK ANALYSIS
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Starting Gemini AI analysis with retry logic...
[2:44:23 PM] 📊 Gemini AI Overall Relevance Score: 75%
[2:44:23 PM] 📊 Analyzed 5 books individually
[2:44:23 PM] ❌ ❌ GEMINI VALIDATION: Response relevance below threshold (75%)
[2:44:23 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "Christmas Miracles" - Score: 95%
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Author Information: 100% - Complete author information provided, correctly identifying all three authors.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Publishing Date: 90% - A specific publishing date is provided. While not recent, it's appropriate for this type of evergreen content.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 95% - The explanations are excellent, providing specific details like 'heartwarming stories,' 'compassion,' and mentions of specific story titles within the book. They strongly justify the book's relevance.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 95% - The 98% score is very well-justified by the 'Gap' explanation, which correctly notes the book's specific focus on miracles within the broader Christmas theme.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ - Remove internal-facing tags like '(manuscript)' and '(metadata)' from the explanation text to improve readability.
[2:44:23 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "Christmas 101" - Score: 95%
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Author Information: 100% - Author information is complete and accurate.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Publishing Date: 90% - The publishing date is provided and is appropriate for a book on Christmas traditions and recipes.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 95% - The justification is strong, correctly identifying the book as a guide to 'festive entertaining' and highlighting its focus on culinary traditions, history, and even movie recommendations.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 95% - The 97% score is well-justified. The 'Gap' explanation logically points out that its primary focus on entertaining may not cover all holiday themes.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ - The response was truncated ('...'). Ensure the full text is presented to the user for a complete explanation.
[2:44:23 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Score: 60%
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Author Information: 0% - Critical failure: Author information is completely missing.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Publishing Date: 0% - Critical failure: Publishing date is completely missing.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 90% - The explanations are very good, clearly describing the book's specific niche as a humorous guide to Southern Christmas traditions.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 90% - The 95% score and its 'Gap' justification are excellent, correctly identifying that the book's regional focus might limit its relevance for a general audience.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ - Must include author and publishing date for every book. This is essential, non-negotiable information.
[2:44:23 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "The First Christmas" - Score: 60%
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Author Information: 0% - Critical failure: Author information is completely missing.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Publishing Date: 0% - Critical failure: Publishing date is completely missing.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 90% - The match explanations are clear and effective, correctly identifying the book's focus on the religious origins of the holiday.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 90% - The 94% score is supported by a very logical 'Gap' explanation that notes the book's specific religious focus may not cover broader cultural traditions.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ - Always provide author and publishing date. This information is fundamental to a book recommendation.
[2:44:23 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "Christmas Cake" - Score: 65%
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Author Information: 0% - Critical failure: Author information is completely missing.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Publishing Date: 0% - Critical failure: Publishing date is completely missing.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 85% - The explanations are good, establishing the book as a novel set at Christmas time and mentioning its key themes and the narrative's culmination on Christmas Eve.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 90% - The 93% score is well-defended. The 'Gap' explanation correctly points out that the book uses Christmas as a setting for broader themes, which slightly reduces its direct focus compared to other suggestions.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ - Ensure that essential metadata like author and publishing date is always included in the response.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ 📊 SUMMARY FEEDBACK:
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ • The response provides a good variety of book types (inspirational, guide, regional, religious, fiction) that are all highly relevant to the broad query.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ • The 'Why this is a match' and 'Gap' explanations are a major strength of the response. They are consistently insightful, well-written, and provide excellent justification for the selections and scores.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ • There is a systemic data retrieval failure, as author and publishing date are missing for three out of the five books. This significantly degrades the overall quality and usefulness of the response.
[2:44:23 PM] ❌ ❌ GEMINI AI VALIDATION FAILED: 75% relevance score (required: 80%)
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ Continuing execution due to soft assertion...
=== END LOGS ===
Scenario Logs: Book Genie Response Validation with Citation Verification
[2:39:59 PM] Navigating to Creative Workspace login page
[2:40:02 PM] Homepage visibility: false
[2:40:02 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:02 PM] ℹ️ Preparing to type query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:02 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for chat input to be visible
[2:40:04 PM] ℹ️ Clearing chat input
[2:40:04 PM] ℹ️ Typing query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:05 PM] ℹ️ Pressing Enter to submit query
[2:40:06 PM] ✅ Query submitted successfully: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:06 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for AI to complete thinking...
[2:40:06 PM] 📋 WAITING FOR AI RESPONSE
[2:40:06 PM] ℹ️ Looking for AI thinking indicator...
[2:40:06 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to appear (max 2 minutes)
[2:40:07 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking indicator appeared - AI is processing the request
[2:40:07 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for thinking indicator to disappear (max 5 minutes)
[2:40:24 PM] ✅ ✓ AI thinking completed - Response should be ready
[2:40:24 PM] ℹ️ Allowing additional time for response rendering
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ AI response wait process completed
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating response for query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 VALIDATING RESPONSE FOR QUERY: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Locating the latest response in chat
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Waiting for response to be visible (max 30 seconds)
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ Response received - Length: 5455 characters
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Response preview: Watch Me WorkInterpreting context for your query...Retrieving Relevant Books for 'books with a Chris...
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Extracting book data from response...
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 EXTRACTING BOOK DATA FROM RESPONSE
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Locating BookGenie response container
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from response
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ HTML content extracted - Length: 41536 characters
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract book data
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED 5 BOOKS
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 EXTRACTED BOOKS SUMMARY
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 1. "Christmas Miracles" - Score: 98%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 2. "Christmas 101" - Score: 97%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 3. "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Score: 95%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 4. "The First Christmas" - Score: 94%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 5. "Christmas Cake" - Score: 93%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📊 Total books extracted: 5
[2:40:27 PM] 📊 Average relevance score: 95%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ Extracted 5 books from response
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Saving 5 books to Excel file: test_results/suggest_5_books_on_christmas.xlsx
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 SAVING BOOKS TO EXCEL FILE
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Target file path: test_results/suggest_5_books_on_christmas.xlsx
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Exporting 5 books to Excel format
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ Book data saved to: test_results/suggest_5_books_on_christmas.xlsx
[2:40:27 PM] 📊 File verified - Size: 19.79 KB
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✓ Excel file creation verified successfully
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 STARTING INDIVIDUAL BOOK VALIDATION (5 books) for query: "Suggest 5 books on christmas"
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 1: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "Christmas Miracles" vs expected: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 98% vs expected: 98%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 98% (expected 98%)
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 4 vs expected 4
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 4 points (expected 4)
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 1 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Book 1 validation completed
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 2: "Christmas 101"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "Christmas 101" vs expected: "Christmas 101"
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "Christmas 101"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 97% vs expected: 97%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 97% (expected 97%)
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 4 vs expected 4
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 4 points (expected 4)
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 2 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Book 2 validation completed
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 3: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" vs expected: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 95% vs expected: 95%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 95% (expected 95%)
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3)
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 3 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Book 3 validation completed
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 4: "The First Christmas"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "The First Christmas" vs expected: "The First Christmas"
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "The First Christmas"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 94% vs expected: 94%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 94% (expected 94%)
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3)
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 4 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Book 4 validation completed
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 📚 VALIDATING BOOK 5: "Christmas Cake"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Starting comprehensive book validation
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating title: "Christmas Cake" vs expected: "Christmas Cake"
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ TITLE VALIDATION PASSED: "Christmas Cake"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Validating score: 93% vs expected: 93%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ SCORE VALIDATION PASSED: 93% (expected 93%)
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Gap similarity calculated: 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ GAP VALIDATION PASSED: Similarity 100.0%
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Why-match points: extracted 3 vs expected 3
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ✅ WHY-MATCH VALIDATION PASSED: 3 points (expected 3)
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ 🎉 BOOK 5 VALIDATION: ALL CHECKS PASSED!
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Book 5 validation completed
[2:40:27 PM] 📊 VALIDATION SUMMARY: 5/5 books passed
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ ALL BOOKS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY!
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING REASON-CITATION MATCHES
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Starting citation validation process...
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 🚀 STARTING COMPLETE CITATION VALIDATION WORKFLOW
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Step 1: Extracting books from AI response
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 EXTRACTING BOOK DATA FROM RESPONSE
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Locating BookGenie response container
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Extracting HTML content from response
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ HTML content extracted - Length: 41536 characters
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Parsing HTML to extract book data
[2:40:27 PM] ✅ SUCCESSFULLY EXTRACTED 5 BOOKS
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 EXTRACTED BOOKS SUMMARY
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 1. "Christmas Miracles" - Score: 98%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 2. "Christmas 101" - Score: 97%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 3. "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Score: 95%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 4. "The First Christmas" - Score: 94%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📚 5. "Christmas Cake" - Score: 93%%
[2:40:27 PM] 📊 Total books extracted: 5
[2:40:27 PM] 📊 Average relevance score: 95%
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Step 2: Extracting citation texts from book elements
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 📚 EXTRACTING CITATION TEXTS FROM BOOK ELEMENTS
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Step 1: Waiting for main book section
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Found 16 total accordion sections
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "1. Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "2. Christmas 101"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "3. The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "4. The First Christmas"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Found individual book: "5. Christmas Cake"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Processing 5 individual book sections
[2:40:27 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 1: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:27 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:30 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:30 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:33 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:33 PM] ℹ️ Found 4 citation buttons for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:33 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/4 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:33 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 1 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:34 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 1
[2:40:36 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): "Christmas Miracles" explores the profound impact of resilience and transformative human connection...
[2:40:36 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 1
[2:40:38 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 1 closed successfully
[2:40:38 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 99)
[2:40:38 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/4 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:38 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 2 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:39 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 2
[2:40:41 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): compassion, selflessness, and the prioritization of giving love...
[2:40:41 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 2
[2:40:43 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 2 closed successfully
[2:40:43 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 63)
[2:40:43 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/4 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:43 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 3 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:44 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 3
[2:40:46 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Christmas Mystery...
[2:40:46 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 3
[2:40:47 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 3 closed successfully
[2:40:47 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 17)
[2:40:47 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 4/4 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:47 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 4 for "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:48 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 4
[2:40:50 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): grand and subtle miracles that defy natural explanation...
[2:40:50 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 4
[2:40:52 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 4 closed successfully
[2:40:52 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 4 extracted successfully (length: 55)
[2:40:52 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:54 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:40:54 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "Christmas Miracles" - 4 citations extracted
[2:40:54 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 2: "Christmas 101"
[2:40:54 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "Christmas 101"
[2:40:57 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "Christmas 101"
[2:40:57 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "Christmas 101"
[2:41:00 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "Christmas 101"
[2:41:00 PM] ℹ️ Found 4 citation buttons for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:00 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/4 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:00 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 1 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:01 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 1
[2:41:03 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): "CHRISTMAS 101" honors the culinary legacy of Dick and Eleanor Rodgers, transforming their tradition...
[2:41:03 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 1
[2:41:04 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 1 closed successfully
[2:41:04 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 159)
[2:41:04 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/4 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:04 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 2 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:05 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 2
[2:41:07 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): blends historical practices with contemporary artistry...
[2:41:07 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 2
[2:41:09 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 2 closed successfully
[2:41:09 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 54)
[2:41:09 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/4 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:09 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 3 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:10 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 3
[2:41:12 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): Gisela’s Deluxe Fruitcake...
[2:41:12 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 3
[2:41:14 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 3 closed successfully
[2:41:14 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 25)
[2:41:14 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 4/4 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:14 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 4 for "Christmas 101"
[2:41:15 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 4
[2:41:17 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): including *A Charlie Brown Christmas* and *It's a Wonderful Life*...
[2:41:17 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 4
[2:41:18 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 4 closed successfully
[2:41:18 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 4 extracted successfully (length: 65)
[2:41:18 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "Christmas 101"
[2:41:20 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "Christmas 101"
[2:41:20 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "Christmas 101" - 4 citations extracted
[2:41:20 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 3: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:20 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:23 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:23 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:26 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:26 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 citation buttons for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:26 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/3 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:26 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 1 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:27 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 1
[2:41:29 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): charming, humorous guide, anyone can learn how to deck the halls, Southern style...
[2:41:29 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 1
[2:41:31 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 1 closed successfully
[2:41:31 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 80)
[2:41:31 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/3 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:31 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 2 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:32 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 2
[2:41:44 PM] ❌ Error extracting citation 2 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South": TimeoutError: locator.waitFor: Timeout 10000ms exceeded.
Call log:
- waiting for locator('[class*="BookCitation-module_paragraph"] span[id*="quotes-citations"]').first() to be visible
[2:41:44 PM] ⚠ ⚠️ Citation 2 extraction failed or returned empty
[2:41:44 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/3 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:44 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 3 for "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:45 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 3
[2:41:47 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): emphasizing that its presentation is as crucial as the dish, reflecting deep-seated cultural etiquet...
[2:41:47 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 3
[2:41:48 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 3 closed successfully
[2:41:48 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 122)
[2:41:48 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:50 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:41:50 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - 2 citations extracted
[2:41:50 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 4: "The First Christmas"
[2:41:50 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "The First Christmas"
[2:41:53 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "The First Christmas"
[2:41:53 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "The First Christmas"
[2:41:56 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "The First Christmas"
[2:41:56 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 citation buttons for "The First Christmas"
[2:41:56 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/3 for "The First Christmas"
[2:41:56 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 1 for "The First Christmas"
[2:41:57 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 1
[2:41:59 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): The stories of Jesus’s birth are the foundation of the world’s most widely observed holiday...
[2:41:59 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 1
[2:42:01 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 1 closed successfully
[2:42:01 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 91)
[2:42:01 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/3 for "The First Christmas"
[2:42:01 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 2 for "The First Christmas"
[2:42:02 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 2
[2:42:04 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): a beacon of light, the fulfillment of ancient prophecies, and a source of universal joy...
[2:42:04 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 2
[2:42:05 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 2 closed successfully
[2:42:05 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 87)
[2:42:05 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/3 for "The First Christmas"
[2:42:05 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 3 for "The First Christmas"
[2:42:06 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 3
[2:42:08 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): the real Christmas story buried in the familiar Bible accounts...
[2:42:08 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 3
[2:42:10 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 3 closed successfully
[2:42:10 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 62)
[2:42:10 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "The First Christmas"
[2:42:11 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "The First Christmas"
[2:42:11 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "The First Christmas" - 3 citations extracted
[2:42:12 PM] 📋 📖 PROCESSING BOOK 5: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:12 PM] ℹ️ Expanding book section: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:15 PM] ✅ Book section expanded: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:15 PM] ℹ️ Expanding "Why this book is the match" section for: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:18 PM] ✅ "Why this book is the match" section expanded for: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:18 PM] ℹ️ Found 3 citation buttons for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:18 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 1/3 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:18 PM] ℹ️ Processing manuscript citation 1 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:19 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN manuscript citation 1
[2:42:21 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): dramatic culmination around Christmas Eve...
[2:42:21 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE manuscript citation 1
[2:42:22 PM] ✅ ✅ manuscript citation 1 closed successfully
[2:42:22 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 1 extracted successfully (length: 41)
[2:42:22 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 2/3 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:22 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 2 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:23 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 2
[2:42:25 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): a heartwarming story that celebrates the close and lifelong bonds among women...
[2:42:25 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 2
[2:42:27 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 2 closed successfully
[2:42:27 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 2 extracted successfully (length: 77)
[2:42:27 PM] ℹ️ Extracting citation 3/3 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:27 PM] ℹ️ Processing metadata citation 3 for "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:28 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to OPEN metadata citation 3
[2:42:30 PM] ℹ️ Extracted citation text (first 100 chars): issues of life and death, faith and love—and good cooking!...
[2:42:30 PM] ℹ️ Clicking to CLOSE metadata citation 3
[2:42:31 PM] ✅ ✅ metadata citation 3 closed successfully
[2:42:31 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Citation 3 extracted successfully (length: 58)
[2:42:31 PM] ℹ️ Collapsing book section: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ Book section collapsed: "Christmas Cake"
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ ✅ Completed processing "Christmas Cake" - 3 citations extracted
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ 🎉 Successfully extracted citations from 5 books
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Step 3: Validating reason-citation matches
[2:42:33 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING REASON-CITATION MATCHES (80% THRESHOLD)
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 4 reasons for: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Reason 1: Checking match...
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas Miracles" - Reason 1: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Reason 2: Checking match...
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas Miracles" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Reason 3: Checking match...
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas Miracles" - Reason 3: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Reason 4: Checking match...
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas Miracles" - Reason 4: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 4 reasons for: "Christmas 101"
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Reason 1: Checking match...
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas 101" - Reason 1: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Reason 2: Checking match...
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas 101" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Reason 3: Checking match...
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas 101" - Reason 3: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Reason 4: Checking match...
[2:42:33 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas 101" - Reason 4: 100% match - PASS
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:42:33 PM] ℹ️ Reason 1: Checking match...
[2:42:42 PM] ✅ ✅ "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Reason 1: 95% match - PASS
[2:42:42 PM] ℹ️ Reason 2: Checking match...
[2:43:23 PM] ❌ ❌ "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Reason 2: 0% match - FAIL
[2:43:23 PM] ❌ ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "emphasizing that its presentation is as crucial as the dish, reflecting deep-seated cultural etiquette and social standing"
[2:43:23 PM] ℹ️ Reason 3: Checking match...
[2:43:34 PM] ❌ ❌ "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Reason 3: 0% match - FAIL
[2:43:34 PM] ❌ ⚠️ Citation text not found in reason: "No citation found"
[2:43:34 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "The First Christmas"
[2:43:34 PM] ℹ️ Reason 1: Checking match...
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ "The First Christmas" - Reason 1: 95% match - PASS
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Reason 2: Checking match...
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ "The First Christmas" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Reason 3: Checking match...
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ "The First Christmas" - Reason 3: 100% match - PASS
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ 📖 Validating 3 reasons for: "Christmas Cake"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Reason 1: Checking match...
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas Cake" - Reason 1: 100% match - PASS
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Reason 2: Checking match...
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas Cake" - Reason 2: 100% match - PASS
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Reason 3: Checking match...
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ "Christmas Cake" - Reason 3: 100% match - PASS
[2:43:44 PM] 📊 📊 CITATION VALIDATION SUMMARY: 15/17 passed (88.2%)
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ 🎉 REASON-CITATION VALIDATION: OVERALL PASSED
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Step 4: Generating detailed report
[2:43:44 PM] 📋 📋 GENERATING CITATION VALIDATION REPORT
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Report generated: 15/17 reasons passed
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation workflow completed successfully
[2:43:44 PM] 📊 📈 OVERALL CITATION VALIDATION: 15/17 (88.2%)
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ REASON-CITATION VALIDATION: OVERALL PASSED
[2:43:44 PM] 📋 📋 GENERATING DETAILED CITATION VALIDATION REPORT
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Generating HTML citation validation report
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ Generated HTML report for 17 reasons
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation HTML report generated and attached
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Citation validation plain text report attached
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking database connectivity...
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Database connected successfully
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Database path: /home/runner/work/HC_Epub_Automation/HC_Epub_Automation/tests/test_data/database.xlsx
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Total books: 5455
[2:43:44 PM] 📊 Database contains 5455 books
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Database book count requirement met: 5455 >= 2020
[2:43:44 PM] 📋 🔍 VALIDATING EXTRACTED BOOKS INDIVIDUALLY AGAINST DATABASE
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 1/5: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "Christmas Miracles"
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "Christmas Miracles" → "Christmas Miracles"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 2/5: "Christmas 101"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "Christmas 101"
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "Christmas 101" → "Christmas 101"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 3/5: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South"
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" → "He"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 4/5: "The First Christmas"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "The First Christmas"
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "The First Christmas" → "He"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking book 5/5: "Christmas Cake"
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Checking if book exists in database: "Christmas Cake"
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ ✅ Database match: "Christmas Cake" → "Christmas Cake"
[2:43:44 PM] 📊 INDIVIDUAL DATABASE VALIDATION SUMMARY: 5/5 books found in database
[2:43:44 PM] ✅ 🎉 ALL BOOKS VALIDATED SUCCESSFULLY AGAINST DATABASE!
[2:43:44 PM] 📋 🤖 VALIDATING RESPONSE RELEVANCE WITH GEMINI AI - PER BOOK ANALYSIS
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Starting Gemini AI per-book relevance validation...
[2:43:44 PM] 📋 🤖 ANALYZING RESPONSE RELEVANCE WITH GEMINI AI - PER BOOK ANALYSIS
[2:43:44 PM] ℹ️ Starting Gemini AI analysis with retry logic...
[2:44:23 PM] 📊 Gemini AI Overall Relevance Score: 75%
[2:44:23 PM] 📊 Analyzed 5 books individually
[2:44:23 PM] ❌ ❌ GEMINI VALIDATION: Response relevance below threshold (75%)
[2:44:23 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "Christmas Miracles" - Score: 95%
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Author Information: 100% - Complete author information provided, correctly identifying all three authors.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Publishing Date: 90% - A specific publishing date is provided. While not recent, it's appropriate for this type of evergreen content.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 95% - The explanations are excellent, providing specific details like 'heartwarming stories,' 'compassion,' and mentions of specific story titles within the book. They strongly justify the book's relevance.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 95% - The 98% score is very well-justified by the 'Gap' explanation, which correctly notes the book's specific focus on miracles within the broader Christmas theme.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ - Remove internal-facing tags like '(manuscript)' and '(metadata)' from the explanation text to improve readability.
[2:44:23 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "Christmas 101" - Score: 95%
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Author Information: 100% - Author information is complete and accurate.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Publishing Date: 90% - The publishing date is provided and is appropriate for a book on Christmas traditions and recipes.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 95% - The justification is strong, correctly identifying the book as a guide to 'festive entertaining' and highlighting its focus on culinary traditions, history, and even movie recommendations.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 95% - The 97% score is well-justified. The 'Gap' explanation logically points out that its primary focus on entertaining may not cover all holiday themes.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ - The response was truncated ('...'). Ensure the full text is presented to the user for a complete explanation.
[2:44:23 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "The Official Guide to Christmas in the South" - Score: 60%
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Author Information: 0% - Critical failure: Author information is completely missing.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Publishing Date: 0% - Critical failure: Publishing date is completely missing.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 90% - The explanations are very good, clearly describing the book's specific niche as a humorous guide to Southern Christmas traditions.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 90% - The 95% score and its 'Gap' justification are excellent, correctly identifying that the book's regional focus might limit its relevance for a general audience.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ - Must include author and publishing date for every book. This is essential, non-negotiable information.
[2:44:23 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "The First Christmas" - Score: 60%
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Author Information: 0% - Critical failure: Author information is completely missing.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Publishing Date: 0% - Critical failure: Publishing date is completely missing.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 90% - The match explanations are clear and effective, correctly identifying the book's focus on the religious origins of the holiday.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 90% - The 94% score is supported by a very logical 'Gap' explanation that notes the book's specific religious focus may not cover broader cultural traditions.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ - Always provide author and publishing date. This information is fundamental to a book recommendation.
[2:44:23 PM] 📋 📖 ANALYSIS FOR: "Christmas Cake" - Score: 65%
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Author Information: 0% - Critical failure: Author information is completely missing.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ❌ Publishing Date: 0% - Critical failure: Publishing date is completely missing.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Why Match Explanations: 85% - The explanations are good, establishing the book as a novel set at Christmas time and mentioning its key themes and the narrative's culmination on Christmas Eve.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ ✅ Relevance Scores: 90% - The 93% score is well-defended. The 'Gap' explanation correctly points out that the book uses Christmas as a setting for broader themes, which slightly reduces its direct focus compared to other suggestions.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ 💡 Book-specific improvements:
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ - Ensure that essential metadata like author and publishing date is always included in the response.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ 📊 SUMMARY FEEDBACK:
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ • The response provides a good variety of book types (inspirational, guide, regional, religious, fiction) that are all highly relevant to the broad query.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ • The 'Why this is a match' and 'Gap' explanations are a major strength of the response. They are consistently insightful, well-written, and provide excellent justification for the selections and scores.
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ • There is a systemic data retrieval failure, as author and publishing date are missing for three out of the five books. This significantly degrades the overall quality and usefulness of the response.
[2:44:23 PM] ❌ ❌ GEMINI AI VALIDATION FAILED: 75% relevance score (required: 80%)
[2:44:23 PM] ℹ️ Continuing execution due to soft assertion...